Hi {{ first_name | default: "Reader" }},

One of my followers sent me a clip from Saturday Night Live this week.

The sketch aired on 7 November (Saturday Night Live, 2026). A man named Alec takes his girlfriend, Jamie, back to the restaurant where they had their first date and proposes. She says no. Then the surprise he booked turns up anyway. The host, Druski, sings a song called "She Said Yes", backed by dancers, a marching band, a bagpiper and a sign-language interpreter. Jamie sits there, wishing the floor would swallow her.

Then Druski announces a very special guest, the father of the bride-to-be. He's part of the show Alec arranged.

Jamie: "Wait. My dad is here? We're no-contact."

Druski: "Then you might not love his feature rap verse."

Her dad raps a few lines, then stops and tells her: "And you're wrong about your childhood. You're not remembering that correctly."

He's on screen for about twenty seconds, and he gets the sketch's sharpest line.

Two things stood out to me.

First, nobody explained the phrase. The writers dropped "no-contact" into one line and trusted a live audience to get it. Entertainment Weekly's recap did the same the next morning, referring in passing to "her no-contact dad" (Hoglund, 2026). Ten years ago that would have needed a sentence of setup. Now it's a two-word character note, and the clip passed a million views on YouTube within two days. No contact has gone mainstream.

Second, look at how the sketch casts them. Jamie is the reasonable one. She made a sensible decision about her father, just as she made a sensible decision about the proposal. Her dad is the butt of the joke. He turns up where he isn't wanted, performs a rap and denies her account of her own childhood. The writers don't make him a villain. They make him a man who doesn't get it, which is how the culture now pictures an estranged parent: wrong about the past and too clueless to know it.

A few people have asked me whether a sketch like this means the mainstream is waking up to no contact as a problem. I don't think it does. The sketch treats cutting off a parent as a normal fact of adult life, with a stock character attached: the parent in denial.

I'll grant the writers one thing. Telling your estranged daughter she remembers her childhood wrong, mid-rap, in front of a restaurant full of strangers, is a terrible idea. Correcting your child's version of events is the worst possible way to reopen contact, and I'll come back to that.

But the line itself deserves a closer look, because the sketch treats it as a man denying reality.

Gaslighting has become the word for this. Merriam-Webster made it word of the year in 2022, after lookups rose 1,740% (Associated Press, 2022). The definition turns on making someone doubt their own memories. So in 2026, a father who says "you're not remembering that correctly" has confirmed the charge against himself. The research on childhood memory tells a messier story.

In 2019, a team at King's College London pooled 16 studies covering 25,471 people (Baldwin et al., 2019). Social services, parents, or teachers documented each person's childhood at the time, and researchers later asked the same people as adults what had happened to them. The two accounts barely lined up. Just over half of the people with a documented record of maltreatment didn't report it as adults. And 56% of the adults who did report maltreatment had no record of it. Agreement was weakest for emotional abuse and neglect, which is where most estrangement stories live.

The authors are careful about what this means, and so am I. Records miss things. A child protection file catches the worst cases and skips the rest, so a missing record doesn't make an adult a liar. The finding is narrower and, to me, more interesting. The childhood that lives in an adult's memory and the childhood on the record are two different things, and nobody holds the tape.

A second study followed 1,196 people, most with court-documented abuse or neglect, into adulthood (Danese and Widom, 2020). Their mental health tracked how they remembered their childhood, whether or not the court record backed them up. People with a documented history who didn't describe themselves as maltreated carried little extra risk. People who described maltreatment carried high risk even when the record showed none.

Think about what that means. The story you tell about your childhood weighs more on your mental health than the documented facts of it. So the words a culture gives you to tell that story carry enormous power. That is the argument of Cut Off. Over twenty years, therapy language gave adult children a new vocabulary for the past, and it rewrote ordinary family friction as harm. A dad who says, "I remember it differently", used to start an argument. Now he's confirming a diagnosis.

So two things are true about the dad in that sketch. He picked the worst possible moment to say it. And memory research gives him more credibility than the sketch did.

If you're a parent and your child tells you you remember it wrong, the finding cuts both ways. Their version isn't a recording, and neither is yours. Which brings me back to the dad. "That never happened" ends the conversation. "I remember it differently, and I want to hear how it was for you" keeps the door open. Cut Off is out now on Amazon in the US and the UK, as a paperback and a Kindle ebook.

If you have an hour to spare, I was a guest on The Resiliency Podcast last week. Marcus Farris hosts it for Mission 22, a nonprofit that supports veterans and their families. The episode title is "Does Therapy Culture Worsen Mental Illness?" We talked about the limits of the trauma model and what estrangement does to mental health. We also got into what helps instead, including breathwork and repairing relationships.

And if you're reading this on Wednesday, the launch is tomorrow night. Thursday 19 November, 6pm to 7:30pm, at Solid Grounds Coffee Roasters in Woodland Park, Colorado. A talk, questions and a signing. Tickets are $50 and include a signed copy, and the last seats are going fast.

Hold steady,

Richard

P.S. Has your child ever told you that you're remembering it wrong? Hit reply and tell me what they said and what you said back. I read every reply.

Disclosure: I wrote Cut Off and earn from every copy and launch ticket sold. None of the research above is mine. This email contains no affiliate links.

References

Associated Press (2022) ''Gaslighting' is Merriam-Webster's word of 2022', 28 November. Available at: https://www.fox9.com/news/gaslighting-merriam-websters-word-2022 (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Baldwin, J.R., Reuben, A., Newbury, J.B. and Danese, A. (2019) 'Agreement between prospective and retrospective measures of childhood maltreatment: a systematic review and meta-analysis', JAMA Psychiatry, 76(6), pp. 584–593. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2019.0097

Danese, A. and Widom, C.S. (2020) 'Objective and subjective experiences of child maltreatment and their relationships with psychopathology', Nature Human Behaviour, 4(8), pp. 811–818. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-0880-3

Hoglund, A. (2026) '"Saturday Night Live" recap: Druski makes history as first digital content creator to host', Entertainment Weekly, 8 November. Available at: https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/tv/reviews/articles/saturday-night-live-recap-druski-043043720.html (Accessed: 9 November 2026).

Saturday Night Live (2026) Proposal [online video]. YouTube, 8 November. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b84KRcISOl8 (Accessed: 9 November 2026).